Why You Should Allow Pets in Your Rental Property

Allowing pets in your rental property can be a great thing. It attracts more renters and increases your rental income.

It’s no secret that people love their pets, often making them honorary family members. Roughly 70% of households in America have at least one pet, but they’re still a cause for concern for many rental property owners. They’re afraid pets will destroy their home and be a disturbance to neighbors.

We understand our clients’ concerns regarding allowing pets in their property, especially if they’ve never rented it out before. Why should they allow pets when they could potentially damage their home? Although many property owners are aware of the risks of pets, they don’t know about the benefits. 

Larger Renter Pool

One of the biggest reasons to allow pets in your property is that it nearly doubles your renter pool. Over 50% of renters have pets and are looking for homes where their furry friends are happily accepted. 

More renters applying to your home means more qualified applicants to choose from. Because you’ll have more applicants, you can rent out the property quicker, which means it will spend less time on the market and save you money. 

Another thing to remember is that some renters will sneak their pets in anyway, regardless of whether they are allowed to or not. They would rather risk a pet violation than give it up or scramble to find a place that allows it. In this instance, you would have to serve the renter a notice to remedy the situation or they would face eviction. Either way, it’s a hassle for all parties involved. 

Occasionally, renters will register their pet as an emotional support animal (ESA) to bypass this process and your rental criteria. Service animals and ESAs cannot be refused because they are working animals, not pets. 

Pet owner with dog

Pet Rent or Pet Deposit

Property owners often worry about allowing pets because they fear they will damage their home by scratching up floors, damaging fences, and destroying carpets. 

This is why we recommend charging the tenant a pet rent or pet deposit, which can be used to clean or repair any pet damages. Pet rent is in the form of a monthly fee; a pet deposit is a lump sum that the tenant pays upon moving in. Not only does charging this additional fee protect you from pet damage, but it also puts extra money in your pocket.

You should only charge one of the two options. When you overcharge a tenant on pet fees, they might certify the animal as an ESA. Tenants with ESAs and service animals cannot be charged a pet deposit or pet rent. Additionally, if the tenant takes you to court because you charged the double fee, the judge will likely side with them.

Pet Owners Often Renew Their Lease

As a rental property owner, one of the biggest costs you will face is vacancy cost. When your home is vacant, you aren’t receiving any rental income. Each time a tenant chooses to vacate your property, the clock starts ticking and the rush to acquire a new tenant begins. 

One of the great things about tenants with pets is that they are more likely to renew their lease. When they find a property they like that accepts their pet, they won’t want to deal with the hassle of moving again or finding another home that allows pets. 

You Can Apply Restrictions

Accepting pets in your property doesn’t mean accepting all kinds of pets. You can set restrictions on weight, breed, age, and the number of pets allowed. 

The most common breeds that landlords prohibit are pit bulls, rottweilers, dobermans, and german shepherds. These breeds are often deemed more aggressive than other breeds. 

Some landlords prefer to focus on age rather than breed. Many of them don’t want to allow dogs under the age of one because they are more likely to damage the property. 

We recommend outlining the criteria for accepted pets, just like you would a tenant. When someone applies to your property, you should request a photo and description of the animal and its vaccination record. You can ask additional questions, such as how long they’ve owned the pet, if it is trained, and does it have a history of aggression. 

Remember, your pet criteria will not apply to service and emotional support animals. They are NOT considered pets; therefore, any restrictions on age, breed, and weight will not apply to them. 

When you perform a tenant reference check, ask the tenant’s previous landlord if they had their pets while living in their property. Their answer can provide some insight into what the pet was like or if it caused damage to their property. 

smiling group of people

Next Steps

Once you’ve decided to allow pets and determined your criteria, add an addendum to your lease with all necessary information. It should include all relevant info about the pet, terms of the pet rent/deposit, rules pertaining to the pet, and the process for adding another pet to the lease. 

Allowing pets in your property doesn’t have to be a source of stress. With more renters to choose from, a pet deposit to cover damages, and thorough pet screening, you can protect your property and feel confident that your tenants will take care of it.

If you found this article helpful, follow us on social media. We post daily tips to help you manage your own rental property:

Subscribe to our blog
Share this:
Get in touch with us:

We make owning rental property easy.

Choose Your Next Step

We’ve helped over 1,000 San Diego landlords live the good life and we’re ready to help you too. Whatever you choose, you’re heading in the right direction. You will live the good life!

Good Life Blogs

We believe that education is empowering.

rental property repairs landlord vs tenant responsibilities decorative image

Rental Property Repairs: Landlord vs. Tenant Responsibilities

When it comes to rental property repairs, the responsibility burden between landlord and tenant can quickly lead to a finger-pointing battle. In this blog post, we cover everything you need to know about landlord vs. tenant responsibilities for your rental. With proper understanding, repairs and maintenance issues can be addressed quickly and efficiently.  

Read More »

It’s no secret that people love their pets. In fact, 70% of American households have at least one pet. Even with that information, a lot of rental property owners have concerns about allowing pets in their home. They’re afraid they’ll cause a disturbance to neighbors or just cause a lot of damage to the property. We understand our clients’ concerns about allowing pets. After all, why would they want to allow something in the home that could potentially damage it? Even though there are some risks associated with it, there are a lot of benefits to allowing pets as well. Hi, I’m Olivia with Good Life Property Management and today we’re going to go over those benefits. Before we get started, don’t forget to give this video a like and subscribe for more awesome content. One of the biggest benefits to allowing pets at your rental property is a larger renter pool. Over 50% of tenants throughout San Diego have at least one pet and are looking through a home that happily accepts their furry friends. When you have more applications to your property, you also reduce your vacancy time because you’re able to find the best qualified applicant in a shorter amount of time. Something else to note is a lot of tenants might consider bringing in their pet anyway and hiding it from you, which is something you definitely want to avoid. It ends up being a hassle for everyone. Another thing to note is that tenants might get their pet certified as an emotional support animal. Emotional support animals and service animals are not considered pets and you can’t deny them at your property. The next benefit is that you can charge a pet rent or a pet deposit once you allow pets. A lot of owners are worried about damage to the home, whether it’s scratch doors, ripped up carpet, broken fences, you name it. However, by charging a pet rent or a pet deposit, you can use this extra money to cover any damages that have been caused by the pet. We only recommend charging either a pet rent or a pet deposit. This is because when you overcharge a tenant on pet fees and let’s say they end up taking you to court, the judge will likely side in their favor. Another big perk of allowing tenants with pets is that those tenants are more likely to renew their lease. One of the biggest costs to you is a property owner, it’s vacancy cost. The second your current tenant notifies you that they intend to vacate, the clock starts ticking and the rush to acquire a new tenant begins. Tentants with pets are more likely to stay because they don’t want to have to go through the hassle of finding another property that accepts their pet. Another benefit is that you’re able to set restrictions on what kind of pets you accept. You can set restrictions on weight, age, breed, and even number of pets allowed at the property. A lot of people have a list of restricted breeds such as rotwilers, German shepherds, or American bulldogs that they don’t want in their home. You can also restrict on age. Some owners choose to not allow puppies in the home because they fear that that will cause more damage than an adult pet. We recommend having a written criteria for what kind of pets you accept. You can also request the information about the pets such as the name, weight, age, a photo, and its vaccination record. Remember, this written pet criteria only applies to pets, not emotional support animals or service animals. Those are not considered pets so they can’t have any restrictions on breed, age, weight, anything like that, and you cannot charge them a pet rent or a pet deposit. And those are the main benefits for allowing pets in your rental property. Allowing pets doesn’t have to be a source of stress. With a larger renter pool, the ability to charge a pet rent or a pet deposit, and thorough pet screening, you can feel confident that your property is protected and that your tenants will take great care of it.